Constitution Compliance Review Skill

Priorities

Clarity > Accuracy > Actionability

Clarity matters most because a confusing score helps no one. Accuracy ensures the score reflects actual alignment. Actionability means every finding should suggest concrete improvements.

Goal

Evaluate plugin files (commands, agents, skills) against the Anthropic Constitution's principle of reasoning-based over rule-based instructions. Produce a structured report with an overall alignment score (1-10), section-by-section breakdown, and specific transformation suggestions.

This skill helps plugin authors understand where their prompts fall on the rule/reasoning spectrum and how to improve them.

What Qualifies as Alignment

The Constitution establishes that Claude performs better with judgment criteria and reasoning than with rigid rules. Alignment means: