Review Research

Perform a structured peer review of research work, evaluating methodology, statistical choices, reproducibility, and overall scientific rigour.

When to Use

• Reviewing a manuscript, preprint, or internal research report
• Evaluating a research proposal or study protocol
• Assessing the quality of evidence behind a claim or recommendation
• Providing feedback on a colleague's research design before data collection
• Reviewing a thesis chapter or dissertation section

Inputs

• Required: Research document (manuscript, report, proposal, or protocol)
• Required: Field/discipline context (affects methodology standards)
• Optional: Journal or venue guidelines (if reviewing for publication)
• Optional: Supplementary materials (data, code, appendices)
• Optional: Prior reviewer comments (if reviewing a revision)