Peer Review

Independent peer review via codex. Translates a natural-language review request into a codex-specific prompt so invocations stay implementation-agnostic.

Step 1: Understand the Request

Identify from the invoking prompt or conversation context:

• Material — the code scope, artifact text, feedback items, or other content under review
• Criteria — reference file paths codex should read directly, inline criteria text, or the material's own domain conventions
• Dimensions — one review concern (single-pass) or multiple independent concerns (fan-out, one per dimension)
• Skepticism guidance — any material-specific instruction for pushing past surface findings; optional
• Output format — finding layout, priority scale, or verdict labels; optional

If no reviewable material is available, stop and state that material is required.

Step 2: Build the Codex Prompt

Assemble the prompt using codex's XML tag conventions (see /codex-exec Prompt Shaping):