hegelian-review
Installation
SKILL.md
Hegelian Dialectical Review
Two-pass adversarial review: find problems (antithesis), then challenge those findings (synthesis). The calibrated verdict table is the deliverable — not either pass alone.
Why Two Passes
A single adversarial review finds issues because that's its job, even when the original decision was sound. The second pass defends the artifact against the first pass's criticisms, producing verdicts that separate genuine issues from false alarms.
Quick Reference
| Step | Agent | Job | Output |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | — | Read the artifact fully | Understanding of scope |
| 2 | Adversarial Critic | Find problems, not praise | Categorized issues list |
| 3 | Steelman Defender | Push back where review is wrong | Per-issue verdicts |
| 4 | — | Combine into verdict table + prose summary | Final calibrated assessment |
Process
Related skills