Slideshow Risk Review

Use When

• A faceless or animation-led short technically works but may still feel static or cheap.
• The visual plan is text-heavy, generated-image-heavy, or motion-light.
• The agent needs a pre-compose or post-render check beyond codec validity.

Core Approach

1. Judge the edit as directed video, not as a set of individually valid scenes.
2. Score repetition across layout, scene type, and shot grammar.
3. Flag visuals that decorate instead of communicate.
4. Penalize motion with no narrative purpose.
5. Reject cinematic claims that are not backed by shot intent, hero moments, or varied scene language.