paper-draft-consistency-editor
Paper Draft Consistency Editor
Check and fix whether a paper draft is internally coherent. This skill is an editor pass, not a reviewer simulation and not a first-draft writer. It makes the title, abstract, introduction, methods, results, figures, tables, captions, related work, limitations, and conclusion agree with the paper's active claims and evidence.
Use this skill for:
- title/abstract/intro/conclusion consistency
- contribution bullet to experiment mapping
- claim strength drift across sections
- terminology, method name, dataset name, baseline name, metric name, and notation consistency
- writing-layer consistency: layout, fluency, argument, technical consistency, style consistency, venue adaptation, and polish edits stay within their intended permissions
- figure/table/caption/main-text alignment
- result prose that no longer matches updated numbers
- unresolved
PROVISIONAL-RESULTorPR-###placeholders - checking whether the draft follows
paper/.agent/writing-contract.md - producing a consistency report or directly editing narrow inconsistencies
Do not use this skill to decide the paper's positioning from scratch. Use paper-positioning-planner for that. Do not use it to write major new prose. Use paper-writing-memory-manager to record stale locations, dependency conflicts, and open writing threads found during consistency checks. Use paper-writing-assistant after consistency issues are identified. Do not simulate hostile reviewers; use paper-reviewer-simulator for acceptance-risk critique.
More from a-green-hand-jack/ml-research-skills
project-init
Initialize an ML research project control root. Use for paper/code/slides repos, shared memory, GitHub Project alignment, agent guidance, worktree policy, and lifecycle handoffs.
39init-python-project
Initialize or enhance a Python/ML project. Use for new repos or forks needing production structure, uv environment setup, and research evidence docs.
37new-workspace
Create Git branches or worktrees for research code and paper versions. Use for experiments, baselines, rebuttal fixes, arXiv/camera-ready branches, and worktree memory.
36project-sync
Sync verified code-side experiment results into paper memory. Use when logs, reports, run docs, or user-confirmed metrics should become paper-facing evidence.
36init-latex-project
Initialize a LaTeX academic paper project. Use for new conference or journal papers needing templates, macros, venue preambles, and writing guidance.
36add-git-tag
Create annotated Git milestone tags. Use when completing a phase, releasing a version, or marking a research checkpoint.
36