rebuttal-strategist
Rebuttal Strategist
Turn real reviewer feedback into a tactical rebuttal plan, experiment plan, paper revision plan, and response draft. This skill starts after reviews arrive. It is not a pre-submission shadow review.
Use this skill for:
- OpenReview review extraction and thread analysis
- reviewer intent and decision-state analysis
- issue board creation from real comments
- deciding which experiments, analyses, proofs, or clarifications to add during rebuttal
- drafting point-by-point author responses
- preparing concise follow-up replies during discussion
- tracking paper revisions promised in the response
- saving rebuttal memory for future rounds
Pair this skill with:
research-project-memorywhen real reviews, issue boards, rebuttal experiments, or promised revisions should persist across sessionspaper-reviewer-simulatorfor pre-submission shadow review or for stress-testing the draft response
More from a-green-hand-jack/ml-research-skills
project-init
Initialize an ML research project control root. Use for paper/code/slides repos, shared memory, GitHub Project alignment, agent guidance, worktree policy, and lifecycle handoffs.
39init-python-project
Initialize or enhance a Python/ML project. Use for new repos or forks needing production structure, uv environment setup, and research evidence docs.
37new-workspace
Create Git branches or worktrees for research code and paper versions. Use for experiments, baselines, rebuttal fixes, arXiv/camera-ready branches, and worktree memory.
36project-sync
Sync verified code-side experiment results into paper memory. Use when logs, reports, run docs, or user-confirmed metrics should become paper-facing evidence.
36init-latex-project
Initialize a LaTeX academic paper project. Use for new conference or journal papers needing templates, macros, venue preambles, and writing guidance.
36add-git-tag
Create annotated Git milestone tags. Use when completing a phase, releasing a version, or marking a research checkpoint.
36