named-persona-adversarial-review
Installation
SKILL.md
Named-Persona Adversarial Review
TL;DR: Abstract roles find abstract problems. Named engineers with documented, sourced philosophies find problems you would actually fix — as long as you cite the real principle and never invent the quote.
Triggers: "review this PR with real engineers" | "named persona review" | "philosophy-grounded review"
Example Output
CRITICAL [Torvalds]: Special-case error handling at auth.ts:47 duplicates the
happy path. Torvalds' documented "good taste" principle: restructure so the
special case disappears rather than adding a branch. (confidence: high — TED 2016)
WARNING [Thompson]: parseConfig() does three unrelated things; the Unix
"do one thing well" principle argues to split it. (confidence: high)
NOTE [Jobs]: Error "EACCES:13" leaks an errno at the user surface; "start
from the customer experience" argues for a human message. (confidence: high — WWDC 1997)
Verdict: CONCERNS — fix CRITICAL before merge.