idea-trial
Installation
SKILL.md
Idea trial
Claude tends to agree with whatever you bring it. This skill makes it argue with itself instead, then lets twelve independent jurors decide.
1. The case
Get the idea in a few sentences: what it is, who it's for, and what "success" would mean (a number and a date if possible). If one of these is missing, ask once, then go with what you have and state your assumptions.
Create a folder idea-trial/ for the outputs and write the case to idea-trial/00-case.md.
2. Arguments
Launch two subagents (Task tool) in one message, in parallel. Each gets only the case.
- Prosecution: "Argue that this idea will fail. Use the strongest real reasons: market, money, timing, execution, competition. Name the single most likely way it dies. Under 200 words. Don't invent statistics."
- Defense: "Argue that this idea will work. Use the strongest real reasons: the demand signal, the unfair advantage, why now. Name the single most likely way it wins. Under 200 words. Don't invent statistics."
Save them as idea-trial/01-prosecution.md and idea-trial/02-defense.md.