reviewing-document-discovery — SKILL.md

Variant: standard · When to use: judging a produced document plan (a manifest of which documents a project will produce) — deciding whether it is sound enough to produce from, then emitting VERDICT: approve|revise with actionable findings.

Overview

This skill is the acceptance gate over a produced document plan — the independent reviewer for what project-document-discovery produces. Loaded by a reviewer holding the plan (and the idea/archetype it was made for), it answers one question: is this the right set of documents — proportional, complete, and producible — sound enough to start producing from? It applies a fixed nine-condition bar, then emits a single machine-parseable verdict plus actionable findings the producer acts on.

The bar is single-sourced 1:1 with the discovery skill's Self-check (its Step 6): the discovery skill self-checks against these nine items so it produces a good plan; this skill asserts the same nine independently (you cannot grade your own homework). It is review-only: it never authors, fixes, or re-plans — it reports findings, the producer revises.

When to activate

• A produced document plan / manifest needs an accept/revise decision before the documents are produced.
• You are the independent gate over a plan project-document-discovery (or any equivalent) produced.
• Re-judging a plan after fixes from a prior revise, or judging an amend (an existing plan + a stated change → a delta).

Do NOT activate when: