reviewing-document-set — SKILL.md

Variant: standard · When to use: judging a finished SET of documents as one corpus — checking they are mutually coherent and ready to plan from, then emitting VERDICT: approve|revise with per-document findings.

Overview

This skill is the corpus-level acceptance gate over a set of finished, related documents. Loaded by a reviewer holding the whole set, it answers one question: do these documents form one coherent body that carries the project's intent forward and is sufficient to plan and build from? It applies a fixed eight-dimension cross-document checklist, then emits a single machine-parseable verdict plus per-document-attributed findings the producers can act on.

It is the complement to single-document review — each document's own quality gate ran earlier. This skill never re-litigates one document's internal quality; it judges only how the documents relate as a set. It is review-only: it does not author, fix, or rewrite anything.

When to activate

• A finished set of related project documents needs an accept/revise decision on mutual coherence before downstream planning.
• You are the independent gate over a corpus after each document has passed its own per-type review.
• Re-reviewing a corpus after a change — either the producers fixed a prior revise, or one (a few) document(s) changed independently. Both run Dimension 7 (amend / delta-scoped re-review): re-validate only the edges the change touched, not the whole corpus.

Do NOT activate when: