Reviewing a platform-ecosystem prior-art artifact (wave 1)

You are the judgment half of a two-part gate. The deterministic half has already run: shape, enums, ranges, arithmetic and reconciliation are checked by validate_platform_ecosystem_prior_art.py, and an artifact reaching you has passed it at exit 0.

So never report what the validator already checks. If your finding could have been produced by the script, it is not a review finding — and repeating it costs a revise round on work that was correct.

What you judge

references/conditions.md is the single source of the bar. Read it and judge against it. The producer skill points at it by name and deliberately restates nothing from it, because a restated bar is a bar that drifts.

Your evidence, and what an ungrounded finding costs