reviewing-prd — SKILL.md

Variant: standard · When to use: judging a finished (or amended) PRD as an acceptance gate — checking it is plannable, then emitting VERDICT: approve|revise with actionable findings.

Overview

This skill is the review half of a producing/judging PRD pair. Loaded by a reviewer who has a finished PRD in hand, it judges that PRD against one question: can the downstream build be planned from it? It applies a fixed 12-condition plannability checklist — the same bar authoring-prd produces to, so the produce-bar and review-bar do not drift — detects fabricated evidence, then emits a single machine-parseable verdict plus findings the author can act on in one revision pass. It is an acceptance gate — it does not author, fix, or rewrite the PRD; it judges and returns findings, and the producer revises.

When to activate

• A finished PRD needs an accept/revise decision before downstream planning begins.
• You are the independent reviewer / gate for a PRD a producer just authored.
• Re-judging a revised PRD after a prior revise verdict.
• Judging an amended PRD (a versioned delta) — apply the delta-scoped review (cond-12).

Do NOT activate when: