paper-reviewer
Installation
SKILL.md
Referee Reports and the Replies That Answer Them
Two jobs, one standpoint. Writing a referee report and answering one are the same competence seen from two sides: you can only prove you answered a question if you can reconstruct the question that was asked.
Pick the mode before starting.
| Mode | Input | Output |
|---|---|---|
report |
a manuscript | a referee report, or a prediction of what referees will attack |
inventory |
a referee report | every ask and sub-ask, in the referee's own words and order |
reply |
a report plus a manuscript | one reply per ask, plus the coverage audit |
grade |
a drafted reply | what an impatient referee would send back |
The contract
A referee report is a list of questions. A reply is a list of answers. The job is to make the two lists line up so exactly that a referee can verify it by scrolling their own report alongside your letter.