prl-revision
Installation
SKILL.md
PRL Revision (prl-revision)
When to trigger
- One or more APS referee reports have arrived
- You received an editor decision (revise / reject / reject-with-appeal-option)
- You need to write a point-by-point response letter
- You are weighing resubmission versus appeal versus retargeting to a PR journal
Read the decision before drafting
APS decisions vary: invitation to revise, rejection that invites resubmission, or rejection on importance/breadth. Match your strategy to the decision:
| Decision | Strategy |
|---|---|
| Revise / minor | Address every point; revise manuscript; resubmit promptly |
| Reject but resubmission encouraged | Substantive revision + a response showing what changed |
| Reject on importance/breadth (science sound) | Decide: strengthen breadth case + appeal, or retarget PR journal |
| Reject on correctness | Fix the science or retarget; do not appeal a valid technical flaw |