review-product-plan
Installation
SKILL.md
Review Product Plan
Contract
Review the artifact that exists; do not silently rewrite it. Start from authoritative anchors and evidence. Separate blocking defects, important improvements, optional polish, and disagreements with the chosen strategy.
Workflow
- Identify artifact type, purpose, audience, status, owner, decision, and governing templates or upstream anchors.
- Read the full artifact and linked evidence before judging.
- Test structural completeness and altitude: outcome, problem, strategy, solution, execution, and verification must not blur.
- Test grounding: claims, users, urgency, metrics, and constraints must trace to evidence or carry an assumption label.
- Test coherence: choices, scope, requirements, measures, resources, dependencies, and rollout must not contradict.
- Test decision quality: alternatives, tradeoffs, non-goals, risks, dissent, and change triggers must be visible.
- Test verifiability: each commitment or outcome needs observable evidence and an owner.
- Return a verdict with the smallest set of changes needed for approval.