review-product-plan

Installation
SKILL.md

Review Product Plan

Contract

Review the artifact that exists; do not silently rewrite it. Start from authoritative anchors and evidence. Separate blocking defects, important improvements, optional polish, and disagreements with the chosen strategy.

Workflow

  1. Identify artifact type, purpose, audience, status, owner, decision, and governing templates or upstream anchors.
  2. Read the full artifact and linked evidence before judging.
  3. Test structural completeness and altitude: outcome, problem, strategy, solution, execution, and verification must not blur.
  4. Test grounding: claims, users, urgency, metrics, and constraints must trace to evidence or carry an assumption label.
  5. Test coherence: choices, scope, requirements, measures, resources, dependencies, and rollout must not contradict.
  6. Test decision quality: alternatives, tradeoffs, non-goals, risks, dissent, and change triggers must be visible.
  7. Test verifiability: each commitment or outcome needs observable evidence and an owner.
  8. Return a verdict with the smallest set of changes needed for approval.

BuildBetter Acceleration

Installs
1
GitHub Stars
4
First Seen
Oct 27, 2026