skill:critique
Skill to critique: $ARGUMENTS
Step 0: Resolve Target
Inspect $ARGUMENTS:
- Empty — ask: "Which skill should I critique? Provide a path (e.g.
skills/dev-plan/SKILL.md) or a skill name (e.g.dev:plan)." - Path to SKILL.md — read it directly; if the file does not exist, report "Cannot find SKILL.md at that path" and stop
- Skill directory — look for
SKILL.mdinside it - Skill name (e.g.
dev:plan,skill-review) — searchskills/,.claude/skills/, andplugins/*/skills/for a match; if multiple matches, list them and ask which one; if no match, report the unresolved name and stop
Once resolved, read the SKILL.md in full before proceeding.
Step 1: Understand the Skill's Intent
Before scoring anything, state in one sentence what this skill is trying to do and what its primary output is. This anchors the critique — every finding should connect back to whether the skill achieves that intent.
Step 2: Evaluate Each Dimension
More from cloudvoyant/codevoyant
mem:help
Use when the user asks about available mem commands or needs help choosing a skill. Triggers on: \"mem help\", \"help mem\", \"what can mem do\", \"mem commands\", \"list mem skills\", \"mem reference\". Lists all mem commands with descriptions, arguments, and usage guidance.
14dev:plan
Use when planning architecture for a project or feature. Triggers on: "dev plan", "architecture plan", "plan architecture", "design architecture", "technical design", "system design for". Produces draft plan artifacts in .codevoyant/plans/{slug}/. Use /dev:approve to promote to docs/architecture/.
14em:review
Use when reviewing an engineering roadmap for quality and realism. Triggers on: "em review", "review roadmap", "sanity check roadmap", "em check", "review this plan". Checks capacity realism, dependency gaps, missing risks, and phasing quality. Auto-launched after em:plan.
13dev:explore
Use when researching technical approaches before building. Triggers on: "explore options", "what are my options for", "research approaches", "compare solutions", "dev explore", "generate proposals", "help me decide between". Runs parallel proposal generation via subagents and outputs to .codevoyant/explore/.
13em:plan
Use when planning a project (epic) or initiative with Linear as tracker.
13pm:plan
Plan a product roadmap for a quarter, half-year, or year. Writes a draft roadmap to .codevoyant/roadmaps/ using capability tiers. Triggers on: "pm plan", "product roadmap", "plan a roadmap", "quarterly roadmap", "annual plan".
13