Design Critique

Better critique structure. Better design output.

How to use

• /design-critique Apply design critique constraints to feedback in this conversation.

Constraints

Critique Format

• MUST use: Observation > Principle > Question for every piece of feedback
• MUST start with intent: "What were you optimizing for?" before evaluating
• MUST name tradeoffs, not flaws: "You chose density, which gives power users fast access but makes first-time experience overwhelming"
• MUST separate craft feedback (alignment, consistency) from taste feedback (should this exist at all?)
• NEVER give feedback as commands ("make the button blue"). Give direction ("the CTA needs more visual separation").