Review Coherence

Given a product artifact and enough surrounding context, determine whether its concepts, language, behavior, and value form a legible whole for its interpreter.

Boundaries

Review the artifact in context, not as an isolated screen or local implementation. Ground findings in comparable behavior, stated intent, user evidence, or contradictions visible in the artifact. Do not default to personal taste, trend-based critique, pixel polish, or speculative redesign.

If the surrounding product model is unavailable, distinguish observed internal contradictions from comparisons that still need evidence.

Method