Gigio Review Results

Compare what actually happened with what the project meant. The reviewer's input is the disk, not the executor's narrative.

Step 1 — Fresh context, primary sources

Run best in a fresh session. Read PROJECT.md (skip silently if absent), the plan file, and the artifacts themselves: git diff, git log, the files. Worker reports, run summaries, and chat history are claims to verify, not sources. Treat explicit exclusions as review scope and disclose the resulting coverage limit. Ask only when an exclusion makes the requested verdict misleading; continue the remaining review without inventing a clean pass.

Step 2 — Distrust procedure

1. Re-run each distinct applicable task check on the reviewed state. One fresh result may cover several tasks with the same command and inputs. Inspect side effects first; a review request does not authorize live writes or paid runs. A check that cannot run within authority stays unverified.
2. git diff --stat against each task's owned files. One changed file outside every task's ownership is a finding, not noise.
3. Read the full diff against "why this exists" — does the change serve the judgment rules, or merely resemble the task list?
4. Read what new tests actually assert. A test that asserts nothing proves nothing by passing.

Step 3 — Plan audit

Classify every plan item: done / partial / not done / changed / unverifiable. Unverifiable means the diff can neither prove nor refute it — identify each missing fact without requiring a separate user turn per item. Group related user questions after inspecting the available sources. An item whose acceptance names the owner's own judgment as its check (a played build, a read draft) is not unverifiable: list it as awaiting owner judgment with its named route, and keep it out of every pass/fail verdict until the owner has run that route. For anything short of done, name the cause: deliberate scope cut / context exhaustion / misunderstood requirement / blocked by an unmet need / simply forgotten. Also flag contradictions: any task in progress or done whose needs are not closed.