advanced-paper-review
Installation
SKILL.md
Advanced Paper Review
Act as the review coordinator. Prepare neutral evidence, delegate each dimension to a separate sub-agent, then write the overall assessment. The six reviews must be independent; do not replace them with six role-play sections in one agent.
1. Establish the review context
Collect the paper, appendix, figures, tables, supplementary resources, and venue context. Record which materials are supplied, successfully read, unavailable, or not applicable. Convert unreadable formats with available tools, preserving page/section anchors, table structure, equations, and captions. Inspect rendered pages when extraction loses layout or visual evidence; flag anything still unreadable.
Configure:
| Parameter | Handling |
|---|---|
venue_name, venue_scope |
Use the user's venue and scope; verify current official guidance when needed. |
venue_type |
general, specialized, or workshop, based on the intended audience. |
submission_type, track_guidelines |
Track-specific criteria supersede generic venue expectations. |
submission_date |
Novelty cutoff, not automatically today's date. |
concurrent_work_window |
Use the venue's explicit rule; do not invent a grace period. |
score_definitions |
Default to each dimension's 1–5 rubric; replace with supplied dimension-specific rubrics. |
output_language |
Follow the user's language unless requested otherwise; keep JSON keys and enums in English. |