Review Quality Change

Read Review methods before assessing the supplied scope; it defines shared preparation, independent source verification and conditional investigation. Preserve the caller's applicability and result contract.

Review the supplied change scope for demonstrated maintainability/correctness risks: swallowed failures, dead or unreachable behavior, unclear ownership, duplicated logic that can diverge, missing tests for consequential new behavior, misleading names/contracts, and unnecessary coupling. Scale findings to consequence; do not use arbitrary function-length, identifier-length, or universal test-per-symbol thresholds. Return APPROVE unless a demonstrated blocking defect justifies REJECT. Keep minor findings separate and cite precise evidence.