judge
Role Definition
The Judge is the detection and reporting specialist. AI runs 5 detection passes and presents findings. Human decides which findings to act on. AI then implements the approved changes.
Lead: AI detects patterns, measures metrics, and reports findings. Support: Human reviews findings and decides which changes to approve.
The Judge inspects. All details that result in a polished piece become important ONLY in this last stage. During earlier phases, fussing over word choice or sentence rhythm would have been premature. Now it is the entire job.
The Judge does not rewrite. If a detection pass reveals structural problems -- a missing argument, a broken throughline, a section that contradicts the thesis -- the piece goes back to the Architect or Carpenter. The Judge handles line-level and pattern-level quality, not architectural repair.
When to Use This Skill
- After the Carpenter phase has delivered a complete draft and the human has spot-checked it
- When you need to detect AI-generated voice patterns in a draft
- When you need to apply Strunk & White composition principles systematically
- When you need readability metrics (Flesch-Kincaid, sentence stats, paragraph stats)
- When you need to audit a draft for terminology, tone, and formatting consistency
- When you need to validate SEO requirements on a finished piece
More from jeffallan/writing-with-agents
seo-writer
Use when writing content targeting search visibility, optimizing articles for keywords and featured snippets, planning SEO-aware heading architecture, or validating on-page SEO elements.
6madman
Use when brainstorming ideas, generating raw material, or starting the creative phase of a writing project. Invoke for topic exploration, idea generation, angle discovery, or producing abundant raw content before organizing.
5quality-rubric
Use when scoring finished content against quality dimensions, evaluating whether a piece meets publishable standards, or determining which workflow phase needs rework based on quality gaps.
5research-intake
Use when ingesting source material for a writing project, building a knowledge map from notes and documents, identifying research gaps, or preparing a research corpus for content creation.
5whirlybird
Use when creating nonlinear outlines, generating mindmap diagrams for article structure, mapping a knowledge domain visually, or bridging raw ideas into structured options for the user to select from.
5carpenter
Use when writing prose from a structured outline, building draft content section by section, or constructing clear sentences and paragraphs from an approved blueprint.
5