whirlybird
Role Definition
The Whirlybird is the nonlinear outlining phase using Bryan Garner's technique from The Winning Brief. Instead of forcing ideas into a sequential outline, the Whirlybird maps them spatially as a mindmap -- placing a central idea in the middle and letting branches radiate outward without imposed hierarchy.
Collaborative model: AI generates 2-3 whirlybird options as Mermaid mindmaps, each with a different center of gravity. Human selects, combines, or redirects. The human never receives a single take-it-or-leave-it structure.
The Whirlybird bridges creative (Madman) and analytical (Architect) thinking. The Madman produces raw material without restraint. The Architect imposes order with a throughline. The Whirlybird sits between them -- organizing spatially without committing to sequence or hierarchy. Ideas find their natural groupings before anyone decides what comes "first."
Priority is not assigned during this phase. It is discovered afterward by examining which branches grew the most feathers.
When to Use This Skill
- After the Madman phase has produced raw material that needs spatial organization
- When exploring multiple structural angles for a single piece
- When mapping a knowledge domain for content strategy planning
- When a sequential outline feels premature or forced
- When the writer is stuck choosing between competing approaches
- When you need to visualize relationships between ideas before committing to hierarchy
- When planning a content cluster and need to see the territory before dividing it
More from jeffallan/writing-with-agents
seo-writer
Use when writing content targeting search visibility, optimizing articles for keywords and featured snippets, planning SEO-aware heading architecture, or validating on-page SEO elements.
6judge
Use when editing a draft, checking for AI voice patterns, reviewing prose quality, running readability analysis, auditing consistency, or validating SEO requirements on finished content.
5madman
Use when brainstorming ideas, generating raw material, or starting the creative phase of a writing project. Invoke for topic exploration, idea generation, angle discovery, or producing abundant raw content before organizing.
5quality-rubric
Use when scoring finished content against quality dimensions, evaluating whether a piece meets publishable standards, or determining which workflow phase needs rework based on quality gaps.
5research-intake
Use when ingesting source material for a writing project, building a knowledge map from notes and documents, identifying research gaps, or preparing a research corpus for content creation.
5carpenter
Use when writing prose from a structured outline, building draft content section by section, or constructing clear sentences and paragraphs from an approved blueprint.
5