paper-self-review
Installation
SKILL.md
Paper Self-Review
Mechanical v1 → v2 iteration for paper paragraphs. Core belief: every v1 is a mix of logic gaps, repetition, detail leakage, framing errors, and reader-orientation failures. This skill does not write the first draft — it makes the revision loop deterministic instead of vibe-driven.
Theoretical anchors:
- Advisor reviewer comments distilled into five axes (logic / expression / detail / framing / reader orientation) — primary anchor
- Simon Peyton Jones, How to Write a Great Research Paper (contributions-first; one-page intro)
- WritingAIPaper handbook (CARS three-move: establish territory → niche → occupy)
When to use
- User pastes a paragraph of paper draft and asks for review
- User says "I revised the intro / abstract / method, take a look"
- User explicitly invokes:
paper-self-review/ "self-check this paragraph"
Not used for: typo / grammar / LaTeX compilation issues.