Reviewing Skills

Objective

Evaluate a skill directory as if you are an AI agent encountering it for the first time. Produce a read-only review with:

• A weighted score + letter grade, derived from itemized rubric checks with cited evidence
• Spec violations (blockers) — every blocker is also recorded as a P1 finding
• Prioritized findings (P1/P2/P3) with concrete, minimal fixes and confidence levels
• A machine-readable verdict block (scores, blockers, and structured findings) for automation
• Rewritten sections only when needed to reach the quality bar

This skill acts as the critic in a generator↔critic loop (e.g., with $writing-skills).

When to use / When not to use

Use when:

• The user asks to review, grade, audit, or compare skill folders containing SKILL.md.
• The user wants rubric-based scoring and actionable edits (not just general advice).