Internal Critique

Simulate a tough-but-fair reviewer before anyone else sees your work.

Reviewer Mindset

Top conference reviewers ask:

1. Is this problem important and unsolved?
2. Is the proposed method novel?
3. Are experiments convincing and fair?
4. Are claims supported by evidence?
5. Is the writing clear enough to follow?

Critique Protocol

Severity Grading System

Every issue must be assigned a severity level. This determines priority and revision strategy.