General Peer Review

Goal

To rigorously evaluate a research plan, manuscript, or simulation workflow prior to execution or publication. This skill acts as an adversarial reviewer, ensuring scientific rigor by identifying methodological gaps, demanding adequate statistical sampling, highlighting weak assumptions, and suggesting necessary baseline comparisons.

Prerequisites

• A completed or drafted piece of scientific writing (e.g., research_plan.md, manuscript draft, or experimental summary).
• Sufficient contextual knowledge regarding the specific simulation or machine-learning methodology being proposed.

Instructions

1. Review Initialization The agent initializes the review process by loading the target document into memory. This can be done by standard reading tools like view_file.

2. Literature-Based Validation The agent utilizes skills like general-query-literature-database or general-deep-research to ground the review in established scientific facts.

   • Perform a literature search regarding the specific materials, methodologies, or baseline properties stated in the text.
   • Point out discrepancies between the proposed approach and standard practices found in high-impact journals.