Review Revision

Overview

Use this skill as a review-and-revision workflow for an existing manuscript, rejected paper, review package, or idea with a concrete direction. Treat the paper as a research system: problem, insight, novelty, idea, method, experiments, writing, and final readiness. The goal is not to summarize what the paper says, but to judge what it actually proves, what reviewers will doubt, and what concrete edits or experiments can fix it.

For the detailed review/revision framework, read references/review_revision_skill.md whenever the task asks for deep critique, revision planning, experiment design, detailed editing, or final checklist work.

Operating Modes

Choose the smallest mode that satisfies the user request.

1. Paper整理: extract the paper map, core claim, contribution type, method logic, experiment logic, and closest related work.
2. 论文拆解: rebuild the author’s intended reasoning chain from problem to evidence; identify where the chain breaks.
3. 深刻反思: evaluate insight, novelty, claim scope, mechanism, theory assumptions, statistical rigor, alternative explanations, experiment sufficiency, and likely reviewer objections.
4. 修改规划: produce a prioritized plan with issue, why it matters, exact fix, target section, and required evidence or edits.
5. 细致修改: rewrite or patch the manuscript section by section while preserving the author’s real contribution and avoiding unsupported claims.
6. 最终 checklist: produce a submission-readiness checklist covering problem, novelty, method, theory, experiments, statistics/reproducibility, figures/tables, writing, naming/positioning, ethics/compliance, and reviewer-risk items.