Test Quality Audit

Judge tests by signal, not volume.

The core question is: What realistic bug or regression would this catch?

Call a test weak only when evidence shows that its signal does not protect a meaningful contract or justify its maintenance cost. If missing context prevents that judgment, state the uncertainty rather than assuming the test has little value.

Goal

Identify the contracts and realistic regressions tests protect, and where their assertions, isolation, or duplication provide misleading evidence or unnecessary maintenance cost.

Do not ask for more tests by default. Prefer a smaller suite that fails for the right reasons.

Success Criteria