Code Critique

Systematic methodology for identifying code problems and communicating them with precision, specificity, and quantifiable evidence. No hedging, no softening, no vague suggestions.

Quick Start

Full code critique:

Perform a brutally honest code critique of this file. Identify all issues with specific line numbers, categories, and severity scores.

Targeted review:

Review this function for violations. Name each code smell, cite the line, and score severity 1-10.