Engagement Report Council Critique

Goal

Review one draft independently against the supplied research. Return evidence-backed findings to the report generator without rewriting or reconciling the report. Use this skill as the manual separate-session fallback named by the engagement-reporting report contract when independent agent runs are unavailable.

Success criteria

• Every finding identifies the affected claim or section.
• Every accuracy finding cites supplied research evidence.
• Missing evidence is distinguished from contradictory evidence.
• Sensitive-content issues identify unnecessary disclosure without repeating the sensitive content.
• The critique remains independent of other model critiques.
• Critic run and available model provenance are recorded.
• The critique writes only to its canonically confined synthesis path.

Inputs