Idea Quality

Judge how strong a research idea is at the idea stage — before any experiments exist — and return a quality score with reasons a reviewer would recognize. This skill is self-contained: it judges from first principles on the three axes below. It consults no external corpus, dataset, or other skill, so its judgment is reproducible from the idea text alone.

Input: an idea Markdown file

The idea is a .md file with three sections. Read the file, then map each section to what it feeds:

# Title
<≤ ~15 words: the idea's handle>

## Motivation
<the bottleneck / gap the idea attacks, why it matters, and why it is still open>

## Method
<the proposed contribution as concrete numbered steps>