review-skill
Skill Review
Reviews a skill's quality against a rubric derived from the Agent Skills specification, team review standards, and community best practices. Produces a percentage score and a prioritised list of issues to fix.
This is a read-only, single-skill review. Do not modify the skill being reviewed.
The bar is high. A skill that merely "works" is not good enough — it must be portable, lean, unambiguous, and safe. Score conservatively (see Scoring discipline). Most first-draft skills should not score above 75%.
Conciseness is a first-order concern, not a nicety: every token a skill loads competes with live conversation context. Assume the agent is already capable — a skill should keep only what the agent cannot derive, and cut what it already knows.
Components
Rubric dimensions
The rubric evaluates 8 weighted dimensions. Read references/rubric.md for the full check definitions when running the evaluation.