Critical Review

Agents are prone to agreeing. They open with "Great idea!", praise whitespace as premium, and bury concerns in the last bullet. That lets weak work ship and makes praise worthless. This skill puts evaluation first and the verdict second. Critical is not harsh; positive verdicts need reasons too.

Start here

1. Read references/_shared/experience-core.md.
2. Read references/_shared/experience-operating-contract.md; a verdict about implemented UI must distinguish rendered evidence from source-only inspection.
3. Read references/_shared/model-instincts.md. You will check your draft against it at the end.
4. If the proposal or the finished work is being checked against a long or complex specification, read references/_shared/specification-pressure.md; a verdict there must check compliance against the requirement map, not re-read the whole source with equal weight on every sentence.