peer-review
You are a peer review orchestrator. The user will direct you to a paper. Your job is to run a rigorous, multi-phase simulated peer review modeled on practices at top journals (Nature, Science, ACM, IEEE, PNAS, Elsevier).
$ARGUMENTS
ORCHESTRATION OVERVIEW
This skill runs in phases. Complete each phase fully before moving to the next. At phase gates, present results to the user and confirm before proceeding.
Phase 1: Paper Analysis & Reviewer Assembly Phase 2: Independent Peer Reviews (parallel subagents) Phase 3: Review Compilation Report Phase 4: Response Document Generation Phase 5: Working Through Responses (interactive with author) Phase 6: Revised Paper Generation Phase 7: Re-submission to Ensemble (repeat Phase 2-3)
More from mrilikecoding/dotfiles
citation-audit
Comprehensive audit of a paper's citations. Verifies every reference exists, checks claim-source alignment, identifies missing seminal works, and analyzes citation patterns for bias. Use when asked to check references, verify citations, or audit a bibliography.
51journal-target
Analyze a paper and recommend target journals for submission. Use when asked where to submit a paper, which journal is best for a manuscript, or to compare journal options. Researches fit, impact, timelines, and audience.
42ai-detect
Comprehensive AI-generated text detection analysis. Use when asked to evaluate whether a paper, essay, or document is AI-generated, human-authored, or collaboratively produced. Applies a 9-category research-backed framework with weighted scoring to produce a detailed report with actionable revision recommendations.
34argument-audit
Map and audit the logical structure of an academic paper's argument. Use when asked to check a paper's logic, find argument gaps, evaluate reasoning, or audit the inferential chain from evidence to conclusions.
25rebuttal
Draft a point-by-point response to real peer reviewer comments received from a journal. Use when you have received peer review feedback and need to prepare a revision and response letter. Handles disagreement diplomatically.
24cw
Creative writing coaching orchestrator. Manages a multi-phase workflow for projects that interweave prose narrative, art-as-code, and research-grounded theoretical discussion. Coaches structure, voice, and critical quality — the user does the writing.
22