Expert Debate Panel

Convene a panel of 4-5 domain experts to conduct a structured debate on any topic. The debate follows a three-act format (Opening, Cross-examination, Synthesis), guided by a neutral moderator. Experts are identified by role labels (no fictional names). Designed for idea critique and tradeoff analysis above all else.

When to use this skill

Use whenever the user wants:

• An idea or proposal stress-tested from multiple disciplinary angles
• A tradeoff analyzed (X vs Y, build vs buy, ship vs delay, hire vs outsource)
• Multi-perspective feedback on a decision or strategy
• Devil's advocate critique with real structured disagreement rather than a bullet list of pros and cons

Do not use this skill for simple factual questions, single-domain technical lookups, or when the user clearly just wants one expert opinion.

Workflow

Step 1: Intake (always run)