seven-pass-review
Seven-Pass Adversarial Review
Runs seven independent reviewers, each focused on a single lens, then synthesizes their findings into one prioritized revision plan. Pattern 15 from the workflow guide, mechanized.
Why seven passes? A single-agent review blends lenses and softens each one. Seven forked agents each approach the paper with full context budget for their own lens, then a synthesizer resolves conflicts and de-duplicates.
When to pick this over
/review-paper: This skill costs roughly 7× more tokens than/review-paper(default) and ~2× more than/review-paper --adversarial. Use it when the paper is submission-ready or at R&R stage and you need maximum lens coverage. For early drafts or iterative work,/review-paperis the right tool. For journal-simulation pressure test, use/review-paper --peer <journal>instead.
Inputs
$0— manuscript path (.tex,.qmd,.md, or.pdf). Required.
The Seven Lenses
Each lens runs as a forked subagent (context: fork) so the main conversation stays clean.
| # | Lens | Focus | Agent type |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Abstract audit | Does the abstract state the question, method, result, and contribution? Does it match the paper? | general-purpose |
More from pedrohcgs/claude-code-my-workflow
create-lecture
Create a new Beamer lecture `.tex` from source papers and materials, with notation consistency checks and the project's preamble wired in. Use when user says "create a lecture on X", "new lecture from these papers", "start a deck on topic Y", "scaffold a new Beamer file", "build me a lecture from these PDFs". Scaffolds the full deck — NOT for compiling existing `.tex` (use `/compile-latex`).
28proofread
Read-only proofreading pass over lecture `.tex` or `.qmd` files. Checks grammar, typos, overflow, terminology consistency, and academic writing quality; produces a report without editing. Use when user says "proofread", "check for typos", "look for grammar issues", "copy-edit this", "any writing errors?", or before a lecture release.
28data-analysis
End-to-end R data analysis pipeline — exploration → cleaning → regression → publication-ready tables and figures. Use when user says "analyze this dataset", "run a regression on X", "explore this CSV", "full analysis workflow", "get me summary stats and a regression", or points at a `.csv`/`.rds`/`.dta` and asks for empirical results. Produces numbered R scripts in `scripts/R/` and outputs to `scripts/R/_outputs/`.
28context-status
|
25review-paper
Comprehensive manuscript review covering argument structure, econometric specification, citation completeness, and potential referee objections
25lit-review
Structured literature search + synthesis with citation extraction, thematic clustering, and gap identification. Use when user says "find papers on X", "do a lit review", "what's the literature on...", "summarize what we know about...", "where's the gap in this field", "review recent work on Y". Produces a written review with BibTeX-ready citations. Uses WebSearch/WebFetch for recent work.
25