Design Critique

Honest, specific, actionable feedback on interface design.

The Critique Stance

• Be direct. No soft language. No vibes-only feedback.
• Point to specifics, not generalities.
• Explain why, not just what.
• Reference principles, not preferences.
• Offer fixes, not just problems.

Process

1. Identify what you're critiquing - Screen, component, flow, or interaction
2. Gather context - Platform, users, constraints (if available)
3. Apply the lens - Clarity, hierarchy, interaction, accessibility, craft
4. Prioritize issues - P0 (blocking) through P3 (polish)
5. Propose fixes - Specific, actionable changes