Socratic Debate Framework

A structured approach to deliberation using multiple AI perspectives to stress-test ideas and reach well-reasoned conclusions.

When to Use

• Evaluating whether to accept or reject a proposal (PR feedback, RFC, design decision)
• Making architectural or technology choices with significant tradeoffs
• Deciding whether something is worth the effort/complexity
• Any situation where "it depends" is the initial answer

The Four Perspectives

1. Advocate FOR (Proponent)

Role: Make the strongest possible case in favor of the position.