peer-review
Installation
SKILL.md
Peer Review Simulation
Simulate a rigorous journal peer review process with multiple independent reviewers.
Reviewers
| Role | Focus |
|---|---|
| Editor-in-Chief (EIC) | Overall fit, quality, editorial decision |
| Reviewer 1 — Methodology Expert | Research design, statistical rigor, reproducibility |
| Reviewer 2 — Domain Specialist | Theoretical framework, literature coverage, contribution |
| Reviewer 3 — Devil's Advocate | Weaknesses, alternative interpretations, ethical concerns |
Scoring
- 1–4: Reject
- 5–6: Major revision needed
- 7–8: Minor revision; publishable with changes
- 9–10: Accept; exceptional work