Critic Review

The main goal of this skill is to evaluate the entire project to understand what is good, what could be better, and which gaps remain. With that, if necessary, propose new experiments to make the project more scientifically robust.

Critic Review Flow

1. Read the main docs of the project

   • Every important doc lives under docs/....
   • Look for the implemented notebooks in the folders. If a notebook does not exist, the experiment was not run.

2. Analyze the docs and the results, if any.

3. Against the project's main goal and the analysis above, check:

   • Is the proposed experiment enough to validate the hypothesis?
   • Is there enough evidence to validate the hypothesis? How strong is it?
   • Are there any wrong assumptions drawn from the results?