Simulate Reviewers

Run a paper through a simulated, venue-calibrated review panel before submission. A NeurIPS main-track reviewer and a SIGSPATIAL demo-track judge reject for different reasons at different thresholds — this skill reproduces that difference: persona-driven weakness hunting, rubric scoring on the venue's own scale, and a deterministic decision-risk readout that tells the authors what to fix while there is still time.

When to use

• "What would reviewers say about this paper?" / "simulate a review"
• "Review this like a harsh NeurIPS reviewer" / "what will Reviewer 2 hate?"
• "Is this good enough for KDD, or should I aim for the short track?"
• "Find the weaknesses before the reviewers do" / "red-team my submission"
• After preflight-check passes (format is clean) but before submitting — this skill judges content, preflight judges compliance.

Inputs