PAW Review Critic Skill

Critically assess generated review comments to help reviewers make informed decisions about what feedback to include, modify, or skip.

Reference: Follow Core Review Principles from paw-review-workflow skill.

Prerequisites

Verify ReviewComments.md exists in .paw/reviews/<identifier>/.

Also verify access to all supporting artifacts:

• ReviewContext.md (PR metadata)
• CodeResearch.md (baseline understanding)
• DerivedSpec.md (PR intent)
• Evaluation artifacts — mode-gated (read Review Mode from ReviewContext.md):
  • If single-model or absent: require ImpactAnalysis.md + GapAnalysis.md
  • If society-of-thought: require REVIEW-SYNTHESIS.md
  • If present artifacts don't match configured mode, report inconsistency