Copy Critique

Standalone evaluation skill. No generation. Receives copy, returns scores and actionable feedback.

Overview

This skill evaluates copy that already exists. It never generates copy from scratch. Input is existing copy text. Output is a structured critique: 7-dimension scores, line-level issues with concrete fixes, and a summary assessment. Optionally rewrites flagged sections when requested or when AI-tell score is high.

Input

Required:

• Existing copy text to evaluate

Optional context (include when available for a more accurate voice match score):

• audience: who the copy is for
• goal: what the copy should achieve
• brand_voice: tone, vocabulary, personality guidelines

5-Step Evaluation Process