Evidence Evaluator Skill

Purpose

Assess source credibility and evidence quality using CRAAP test and evidence hierarchies.

Trigger Conditions

Keywords: "evaluate source", "is this credible", "check evidence", "study quality", "reliable source"

Procedure

Phase 1: CRAAP Test

C - Currency: How recent? R - Relevance: Fits the need? A - Authority: Qualified author? Reputable publisher? A - Accuracy: Verifiable? Sources cited? Peer-reviewed? P - Purpose: Why created? Bias present?

Score each: 0-5 (Weight: R=1.5x, A=2x, A=2x, others=1x) Total score / 37.5 = Credibility %