judge
Installation
SKILL.md
Judge
Overview
Evaluate agent task outputs against a three-dimension rubric and produce structured verdict records. The judge operates as a quality gate at the task completion boundary, scoring outputs on Semantic accuracy, Pragmatic usefulness, and Syntactic consistency.
Rubric: Three KLS Dimensions
The rubric reuses three dimensions from the KLS (Krogstie-Lindland-Sindre) quality
framework defined in disciplined-quality-evaluation:
| Dimension | Question | Criteria |
|---|---|---|
| Semantic | Does it accurately represent the domain? | Factual correctness, domain terminology, no contradictions |
| Pragmatic | Does it enable the intended decisions/actions? | Actionable, useful, addresses the task goal |
| Syntactic | Is it internally consistent and well-structured? | Format compliance, structural completeness, no broken references |