Review Paper

v1.1 — Pre-submission self-review combining econ-native evaluation with adversarial stress testing

Simulate a rigorous peer review of an academic manuscript before submission. Combines economics-specific review criteria (identification strategy, econometric specification) with a Devil's Advocate stress test and editorial synthesis.

Argument: $ARGUMENTS

• Path to a paper file (.pdf, .tex, .qmd, .md, .docx)
• Or a project name (will look for the paper in the project's standard locations)

Modes (append to argument):

• full (default) — 3-pass review: Econ Referee + Devil's Advocate + Editorial Synthesis
• quick — Single-pass referee report only (skip DA and synthesis)
• methodology — Deep dive on identification and econometrics only
• da-only — Devil's Advocate stress test only (skip balanced review)

Example: /review-paper ~/Dropbox/Github/bd-social-norms/paper/main.tex full Example: /review-paper dep-dts quick