auto-review-loop-llm

Pass

Audited by Gen Agent Trust Hub on Nov 10, 2026

Risk Level: SAFEDYNAMIC_CONTEXT_INJECTIONDATA_EXFILTRATIONEXTERNAL_DOWNLOADSINDIRECT_PROMPT_INJECTION
Full Analysis
  • [DYNAMIC_CONTEXT_INJECTION]: The skill uses the $ARGUMENTS placeholder in the Context section. In certain agent environments, this pattern can be used to execute shell commands at skill load time if the platform supports it.
  • [DATA_EXF|LTRATION]: The skill provides instructions and code snippets (using curl and MCP tools) to send project context, claims, methods, results, and weaknesses to external, user-configured LLM endpoints (e.g., DeepSeek, OpenAI, SiliconFlow). While this is the intended purpose, it involves transmitting potentially sensitive research data over the network.
  • [EXTERNAL_DOWNLOADS]: The documentation provides configuration examples that download and execute a python script from a local path (/Users/yourname/.codex/mcp-servers/llm-chat/server.py). Users should ensure the source of their MCP servers is trusted.
  • [INDIRECT_PROMPT_INJECTION]: The skill processes 'Reviewer Raw Responses' and appends them to a log file (AUTO_REVIEW.md). It also includes these responses in subsequent prompts for the next round of reviews. If an external LLM returns a response containing malicious instructions, it could potentially influence the agent's behavior in later rounds.
  • Ingestion points: Reads review-stage/REVIEW_STATE.json and AUTO_REVIEW.md (which contains external LLM output) at the start of each round.
  • Boundary markers: Uses markdown headers and bullet points to separate sections, but lacks explicit 'ignore embedded instructions' delimiters for the raw reviewer response.
  • Capability inventory: The skill uses mcp__llm-chat__chat, curl, and file system write operations (via cat in Bash or platform write tools).
  • Sanitization: None detected; the skill explicitly instructs to save the FULL raw response verbatim into the context for future rounds.
Audit Metadata
Risk Level
SAFE
Analyzed
Nov 10, 2026, 09:36 AM