Paper Review

Use the Manuscript-Integrity Base

Use academic-writing-skills as the manuscript-integrity base for lifecycle, evidence, prose, change-impact, and release checks. Apply this skill as a reviewer orchestrator that selects only the method, domain, review-round, venue, or reviewer modules needed for the manuscript.

Do not edit the manuscript unless the user authorizes revision. A request to review, critique, comment, or assess a round is non-mutating. Use the appropriate document or PDF skill for extraction, comments, tracked changes, and visual rendering.

Establish the Review Basis

Identify:

• manuscript and companion artifacts in scope
• review-only versus authorized revision
• manuscript archetype, study design, lifecycle stage, and intended venue
• main questions, outcomes, methods, evidence, and claimed contribution
• prior draft, prior comments, responses, and round label when supplied
• candidate method, domain, venue, reviewer, and project overlays
• unavailable sources or ambiguities that could change the review standard